Asphalt Driveway Resurfacing vs. Replacement: Which Is Right For You?

Your driveway plays a key role in your home’s appearance and functionality, but over time, even the best asphalt surfaces begin to show wear. Cracks, potholes, and fading can all impact your driveway’s look and performance. When this happens, homeowners often face a critical decision: should you resurface your asphalt driveway or completely replace it?

Total Paving & Brick Services helps homeowners across Northern Illinois and Southeastern Wisconsin determine the most effective and cost-efficient solution. Here’s how to know which option is best for your driveway.

Understanding Asphalt Driveway Resurfacing

Asphalt resurfacing, also called overlaying, involves applying a new layer of asphalt over the existing driveway surface. This method restores a smooth, even appearance while reinforcing the structure underneath.

When Resurfacing Is a Good Option

Resurfacing is ideal if your existing asphalt driveway is still structurally sound. If the foundation is intact but the surface has cracks, fading, or minor potholes, resurfacing can restore both beauty and durability without the cost of full replacement.

Homeowners typically choose resurfacing when:

• Cracks are less than ¼ inch deep.
• There are no major drainage or foundation issues.
• The surface shows aging, fading, or mild deterioration.

Benefits Of Asphalt Resurfacing

Resurfacing is a faster and more affordable solution than full replacement. It provides a refreshed look, improved traction, and additional protection against water damage. When done by professionals, resurfacing can extend your driveway’s lifespan by 8 to 15 years.

Understanding Asphalt Driveway Replacement

Driveway replacement involves removing the existing asphalt entirely and rebuilding the base before installing a new surface. This process addresses deep structural problems that resurfacing alone can’t fix.

When Replacement Is Necessary

If your driveway has large cracks, deep potholes, or drainage problems, replacement is likely the best choice. These issues often signal base damage, meaning resurfacing would only offer a temporary fix.

Replacement is recommended when:

• The driveway base is unstable or eroded.
• Cracks are wider than ¼ inch or appear in multiple areas.
• Drainage problems cause pooling or erosion.
• The asphalt is more than 20 years old and heavily worn.

Benefits Of Driveway Replacement

A full replacement provides a fresh start with a stable foundation that can last 20 years or more. It ensures better drainage, improved safety, and long-term value. Though the upfront cost is higher, a new installation offers superior durability and performance, especially in the Midwest’s harsh freeze-thaw climate.

Comparing Costs & Longevity

Resurfacing generally costs less than half the price of a full replacement, making it appealing for driveways with minor wear. However, if the underlying structure is compromised, resurfacing may not last as long and could lead to more frequent repairs.

Replacement is a higher investment upfront, but it eliminates recurring problems and provides decades of reliable performance. At Total Paving, our experts perform thorough inspections to ensure you receive the best long-term value for your property.

How Total Paving Ensures Lasting Results

Whether you choose resurfacing or replacement, proper preparation and professional installation are key. Our team at Total Paving & Brick Services uses advanced equipment, premium asphalt materials, and precise grading techniques to ensure your driveway is durable, attractive, and built to withstand Midwest weather conditions.

We also offer sealcoating, crack filling, and drainage solutions to help you protect your investment for years to come.

Contact Total Paving for Expert Driveway Solutions In Northern Illinois & Southeastern Wisconsin

Not sure whether resurfacing or replacement is right for your driveway? The experts at Total Paving are here to help. We’ll evaluate your driveway’s condition, discuss your goals, and recommend the best solution for lasting results.

Contact us today to get a FREE quote and learn how our team can restore your driveway’s strength, beauty, and performance.